• GameSpy.com - Reviewed by Steve Steinberg [66/100]. "There are better ways to relive your college years." Includes screen shots. (September 6, 2003)
  • GameZone - Reviewed by Louis Bedigian [7.7/10]. "989 Studios's best release yet, but is still not quite perfect." (September 2, 2003)
  • Gaming Age - Reviewed by Brian Peterson [Grade: B-]. "Hopefully folks will get past the visuals which, while decent, still fall behind EA in overall standards."
  • GameSpot - Reviewed by Ryan Mac Donald [5.7/10]. Features screen shots, gameplay movies, and cheat codes. (September 9, 2003)
  • Gamer Dad - Reviewed by Dr. Matt J. Carlson [3/5]. "NCAA GameBreaker 2004 is about as kid-friendly as you would expect a college football game to be." (March 4, 2004)